How not to implement reforms: The Zanzi bar case

Mwalimu-G

Elder Lister
Zanzibar beer: Alcohol shortage hits Tanzania's spice islands
    • Published
      5 February
Share
Tourists sunbath on deckchair at an hotel on Nungwi Beach, on the island of Zanzibar,on December 30, 2017.
IMAGE SOURCE,AFP
Image caption,
Hotel operators have warned of mass lay-offs if the situation is not addressed
By Alfred Lasteck in Stone Town & Wycliffe Muia in Nairobi
BBC News

The spice islands of Zanzibar are facing a shortage of alcohol which threatens the tourism sector of one of Africa's top travel destinations.
Tourism generates about 90% of the Tanzanian archipelago's foreign revenue.
Prices of beer have shot up by almost 100% after the supply chain was disrupted by a sudden change of importers.
The islands' tourism minister resigned recently citing poor work conditions.
However, some have linked his resignation to the issues with alcohol supplies.
Known for their stunning sandy beaches and rich cultural heritage, the Indian Ocean islands are popular with tourists from around the world.

Last year, Zanzibar was ranked among the 10 best travel destinations in Africa by several tour magazines.
But hoteliers now warn that the problems over alcohol supply might make the island lose its tourism shine.
Zanzibar beach

Image caption,
Zanzibar is known for its stunning sandy beaches
Several tourist hotels along the Matemwa beaches in the north of Zanzibar's main island are only serving soft drinks and people in that area say they have to go to the main city, Stone Town, for alcohol.
Mr Mshenga's business selling beer and sea food has been badly hit.
"We are running short of beer at my bar, and I just have a stock of soft drinks," he told the BBC. "The government has to take action. It is the high season now, it is very hot and these tourists need joy, they need cold beer on these beaches."
An American tourist, who did not want to be named, said: "I love Zanzibar and its beaches. The people are amazing and only challenge I feel now is I can't get hard liquor. I want to have spirits or even whisky but nothing is found in the hotel - they instead advised me to order it from Stone Town."

The local manufacture of alcohol is banned in Zanzibar, whose population is largely Muslim.
Most of the alcohol sold on the islands comes from mainland Tanzania, while some is imported from South Africa.
The initial shortage early this year began when the Zanzibar Liquor Control Board (ZLCB) delayed renewed permits for the three established importers - One Stop, Scotch Store, and ZMMI.
It is not clear why the licences of the three firms, which had supplied alcohol to the island for more than two decades, were not renewed.
For alcohol importers to get licensed, they must be Zanzibari-born residents with a clean tax record, a warehouse, and a delivery vehicle.
Additionally, importers must also pay a $12,000 (£10,000) annual fee to the regulatory board.

Last month, ZLCB granted licences to three new companies - Kifaru, Bevko and Zanzi Imports - but hoteliers say they are still struggling to meet the demand.
The new firms are reportedly entangled in a lengthy vetting process amid reports that some non-Zanzibaris are involved in the operations of the companies in contravention of the law.
The situation has been complicated further after the three previous licence holders filed appeals, asking the government to renew their liquor import permits.
Zanzibar's liquor stores are struggling to keep shelves stocked.
Empty liquor store in Zanzibar

Image caption,
Zanzibar's liquor stores are running out of stock
"There is an alcohol shortage in Zanzibar and we've already informed authorities about the tourism sector's situation," Rahim Mbarouk, chairman of the Zanzibar Tourism Investment Association, told the BBC.
The price of beer has gone up from 2,500 shillings ($1; £0.80) to 5,000 shillings, according to Neema Meena, a frequent traveller to Zanzibar from mainland Tanzania.
Some popular alcohol brands, like Safari, are said to be completely unavailable.
"This shortage hits hard," Frank John Kahamu, secretary at the Amani Alcohol Merchants Union, told privately-owned The Citizen website.
Mr Kahamu said more than 3,000 workers could lose their jobs if the situation continued.
"We can't keep paying wages with empty shelves."
ZLCB chairperson Juma Chum declined to respond when the BBC reached out for comment.
But Issa Mahfoudh Haji, a senior official in the Ministry of State responsible for the ZLCB, told state media: "We have heard about the complaints and we need to find details about the controversy."
Simai Mohammed Said resigned as tourism minister last week, citing "unfavourable and disruptive working conditions".
His resignation has been linked to a recent press conference where he publicly accused the ZLCB of mismanaging the liquor industry.
"If we fail to plan, including having enough stock of alcoholic beverages, we frustrate our visitors," he said, according to state media.
But while swearing in the new tourism minister on Thursday, Zanzibar President Hussein Mwinyi suggested Mr Said had a conflict of interest.
Reports link one of Mr Said's relatives to one company whose licence was not renewed.
"If you have a bar, and you find out authorities have not given access to alcohol to your bar, then be transparent and tell the public that there is conflict of interest," President Mwinyi said, referring to Mr Said.
The BBC has approached Mr Said for comment.
The crisis comes amid soaring tourist arrivals in the semi-autonomous Tanzanian islands.
They witnessed a 16% surge in international visitors last year, welcoming a record more than 630,000 tourists, according to the annual tourism report.
The tourist upsurge was due to significant increases of arrivals from India and Russia, the report said.
 

Mwalimu-G

Elder Lister
This is the same kind of shitshow we saw in our coffee here. We branded our marketers "cartels" and recalled their licences, only we had not planned where go take the coffee after they are gone.
As a result a whole season's coffee beans -51 million kilos- are losing flavor in stores.
 

Snowball

Lister
Without apologies, most of us African are still mentally evolving and this Zanzibar scenario is a case in point. Meanwhile back here at home, Hapa Kilifi South, we have not seen a drop of water in the past 2.5 weeks. No one cares and no one is responsible.
 
Top