Search results

Miscarriage is in premise 4! But Rape is in premise 4? You wrote it! Unless you dont know what a premise is? If those are premises and your conclusion therefore is Rape is healthy, then your argument would be sound and your conclusion valid. Is it insane to have such an argument? Absolutely...

Abortion is literally my first premise! You keep misrepresenting my argument to knock it down. The very definition of strawman. Your premises do not include Rape in any of them. You cannot then introduce it in the conclusion. You have literally repeated the same mistake again despite it being...

Your conclusion must arise from the premises you state. Rape appears nowhere in any of your premises. Hence your syllogism in illogical. I dont think you are familiar with how a syllogistic argument is structured because you keep making the same mistake over and over. These are the basics of...

If a = b B= c then it must be true that A = C. This is what I have laid out. So yes, miscarriage is an abortion. See my edited comment above about steelmaning your position

I dont consider the foetus/embryo a person before those 12wks based on what i believe is brain development to uniquely distinguish it. So from this time we have a dilemma as to how not to impede the bodily autonomy of either party. Do i have a solution to it? No. But from my position I provided...

Is the end result the termination of the pregnancy? If yes, then the arguement structure is sound and valid and must then be NECESSARILY true. Thats just how a sound logical argument is structured. If i was to steelman your position, What you should be arguing is the definition of abortion.

Your syllogism fails because you have created 2 distinct subsets and then equated them. For your argument to flow in any logical sense, it would have to be: P1. Dogs breathe air P2. All humans are dogs Conclusion. All Humans breathe air. This is invalid argument because P2 is not valid. from...

there is no medical definition of murder. Homicide, murder, suicide, manslaughter etc are legal definitions of a death occurrence. if there, please provide it. the syllogism would be thus by your logic: Premise 1: Abortion is the termination of a pregnancy. Premise 2: Abortion is murder...

Unless one is in a theocracy, then by all means use whatever religious rules to set your laws. However, if your governing system is not faith based, it would be absurd to use faith as a basis for any legal ruling. I would argue that culture should also not be used in the legal ruling. Because...

If you read the medical definition of abortion there is no conflation. It covers both in the umbrella of the definition. I agree. So it is incumbent on those claiming that a 1wk embryo is the same a 1wk old baby and everything inbetween. The fact that you use works like "okay" and "is it...

I partially agree with you. Yes, you normal daily life cannot be defined by medical terms, however, the question of abortion directly requires you to look at it from a scientific/medical view alone. Why? because you now enter murky waters of philosophy which no court can make any ruling. You...

I say abortion should be addressed in its strict terms. The reason it is phrased that is so that there is no bias carried over. When the definition is the termination of a pregnancy, anything and everything that makes a pregnancy stop in those strict terms an abortion. Do you see the...

The medical definition of abortion is the termination of a pregnancy. Words like "life" "kill" or "murder" are avoided because of the religious, social and cultural meanings they carry. And it is a medical/scientific term that specifically avoids those tones. The reason it is worded that way is...

These two statements are in diametric opposition to each other. You in one sweep categorised it as murder (which has a very precise legal definition) and then also given exceptions for the same thing. At what point is it ok for an abortion procedure to be done and not another? Where do you draw...

Im sure FP hukaa hivi...naweza mnunulia 50x100 pale Joska kama tip

@The.Black.Templar...no wonder you like tp

Church elder @Aviator hawezi achwa nyuma

@mzeiya is ready for Eid

The reason @Mwalimu-G was delayed at the market..